Customer Reviews

We pay attention to all of our customer feedback and appreciate all of it, thank you!
You can leave your own feedback for New York Deli Pizza around the web here.

“My husband just started a new job in Williamsburg. We heard the food was good at New York Deli so we decided to pick up some food one afternoon to bring home. We had about a 30 minute trip home. I’m a creature of habit and get the same things when I eat out. I decided to try something new and got the grilled chicken sub. It was fantastic. I’m addicted to that sub. My husband really liked the Julienne salad and his club decker on toast. We will definitely be back.” – Kimmie R

“My friend always gives this place great reviews…so I gave it a shot. Ordered the grilled chicken sub. It took a while to come out, but when I got the sandwich i understood why. The chicken was grilled up perfectly! The sandwich was big! A lot of people were coming in to pick-up orders. I come here every time I’m in Williamsburg now!” – Henry

“What a gem. We are from the North and LOVE this place. Great atmosphere and respect for NY traditions (pics of towers and skyline) and old school food. Thanks for all that you do!” – Dan M.

“We visited New York Deli back in 2012 and really enjoyed the food and service. We vowed that whenever we are in Williamsburg Va, we will always stop into New York Deli. My wife really enjoyed the Reuben Rye. She gave me a taste and now I am hooked on the Reuben Rye. Can’t say enough about New York Deli: Great Food, Great Portions, and Great Price. Visit if in the area, you will not be disappointed.” – Benjamin K. & Debra K., Woodbridge, VA

“We love stopping in and grabbing lunch or dinner when heading to Busch gardens or water country USA during the summer months. My husband and I will take the 40 min drive for a date night. I have no complaints on the food always leaved stuffed and taking a box home for lunch or dinner the next day. Prices are reasonable and the employees are super nice.. Establishment is very clean!” – Julie R., Spring Grove, VA

“I only get to visit here a few times a year but they make the best subs anywhere I go. I have been ordering the same Roast Beef Sub (The Chandler) for 40 years. They make it perfect every time. I will drive an hour out of my way to have a sub here. I wish they wouldn’t close on Monday. Love this spot!!!” – Jimmy P., Crofton, MD

“So good. I have had an amazing turkey sub that was enough for 2 meals, and the pizza, well its all in the sauce right? Yum. My friend thought the Reuben was wonderful.”- Tia S., Williamsburg, VA

“Great food! Great service! What more could you ask for? My family made it a point to eat here on our vacations from abroad. Try any of the hot subs, you will not regret it.”- Chris G., Williamsburg

“Just left and I have to say its one of the best places in Williamsburg best subs in the city!” – Joel O., Williamsburg, VA

“Great casual venue with good food and reasonable prices. I love that it has phone ahead ordering and that if you order inside, you just walk up to the counter. I’m not a fan on waiting on wait staff to take my order and bring my drink so I prefer self serve style. Delicious food! Generous portions, even in the kid’s meals. Will definitely return. – Judith S., Williamsburg, VA

“Whenever I’m in Williamsburg, I know I can get a solid sandwich from NY Deli. I’m a big fan of the pastrami but recently had the Italian sub and thought it was very good. I’d like to try the pizza someday too but haven’t yet. They’re usually pretty crowded but it cycles fast. – James M., Richmond, VA

“If you’re looking for a a great deli sandwich, NY Deli really hits the spot. I have been a fairly regular diner at this restaurant over the past few years and frankly I usually order a Pastrami sub or a pizza which is my preference. The interesting thing to me about this place is that in a resort town like Williamsburg, VA with literally 150 restaurants from which to choose, NY Deli is virtually always packed! I will personally attest to the consistent quality of the food but the sheer volume of local attendance at their door each day says a lot. Highly recommended if you haven’t given them a try.” – John T., West Point, VA

“The food is fantastic! Great environment to groups and teams to eat. You can put tables together for larger groups or take them apart for smaller groups. Something for everyone! “The food is fantastic! Great environment to groups and teams to eat. You can put tables together for larger groups or take them apart for smaller groups. Something for everyone!” – Beth B., New Kent, VA

“Every time I head up to Williamsburg or Richmond, I stop by New York Deli & Pizza for a sub and fries. It is my favorite place to eat at in that area! The service is wonderful and the atmosphere is awesome. There is a huge variety of uniquely named sandwiches to choose from, and you have the choice to have it hot or cold! There are televisions everywhere and a good-size dining area. New York Deli & Pizza never lets me down!” – Barb W., Virginia Beach, VA

“My mom brought me here — it’s her favorite sandwich place — and we both got the steak-and-cheese’s, which were DELICIOUS and big enough to take home and reheat for dinner. Good service, extensive menu, inexpensive, savory food — a win-win.” – Jethro T., Silver Spring, MD

“Finally went, and at the peak of the lunch rush. Although the place was packed, they are super efficient and friendly… and in less than 10 minutes we had our meal. Mega sized sandwiches on fresh bread, true deli coleslaw, perfect fries… We were in heaven! Can’t wait to go back to try more of their samplings… especially the carrot cake which looked heavenly.” – Jennie

Great food, great prices, great atmosphere, huge portions!!! I love to go with the family, order a little bit of everything and share. I never leave empty or unhappy. Except for on Mondays when they are closed!” – Katie H.

“Just like home (New York)! Since leaving New York many years ago I haven’t been able to find a hero sandwich that would be just like home. WELL it’s here at New York Deli GREAT sandwiches and pizza if you close your eyes while you eat you can even hear the subway trains. Really good fresh food and a good reasonable price. Bring the family so all can enjoy. (This is not Subway).” – Trip Advisor user

“Not your ordinary sub. I had lunch at New York Deli, I finally made my decision after looking at ALL the subs and placed my “special” order. No problem with that they are happy to serve what you want. The wait was not to long and the sub was SO worth it. I intended to only eat half but I had forgotten how much I like Smithfield ham and even though I was almost to full for the rest of the afternoon I just had to eat the whole thing. I will be going back soon. – Katrina W.

“Must go! When in Williamsburg, this is the deli to try. Fantastic slovaki – super subs – had an italian, steak, and jefferson. Also ordered a pizza to go on a different night. Great for a family dinner!” – UrbanSpoon User

“Best Deli ever. The manager is always there making sure everything is just perfect. We love it. Thanks for making it a perfect place to enjoy our favorite sandwiches and meals.” – Peggy & Ned M.

“If you’re looking for a a great deli sandwich, NY Deli really hits the spot. I have been a fairly regular diner at this restaurant over the past few years and frankly I usually order a Pastrami sub or a pizza which is my preference. The interesting thing to me about this place is that in a resort town like Williamsburg, VA with literally 150 restaurants from which to choose, NY Deli is virtually always packed! I will personally attest to the consistent quality of the food but the sheer volume of local attendance at their door each day says a lot. Highly recommended if you haven’t given them a try.” – John T.

“Food is delicious and portions are huge. Best place for subs in all of Williamsburg.” – Google User

“Great stromboli and subs! My family has been going to NY Deli since it was opened in its original location. How happy were we when it grew in size and moved to the old Burger King. The subs are so delicious and we’ve always been a fan of the huge strombolis. Kiki and family have established a great “”go-to”” place over in the Norge/Lightfoot area. I haven’t tried the Greek food there, but I’m sure its just as great!” – Yellow Pages Reviewer

We’d love to hear from you!

Please feel free to leave us a review using the form below. If you prefer to review the New York Deli & Pizza Restaurant using your favorite social media, or search engine, you can…click here.

* indicates required field

We respect your privacy

All reviews added to this page will only include your first name and last initial. If you wish to have your review added to this page, but wish to remain anonymous, please state that in your customer comment.

New York Deli & Pizza Restaurant, Williamsburg

757.564.9258
Call with your mobile
Call with Skype
6546 Richmond Road
Williamsburg, VA 23188
Get directions to our location.
Employment Application

Restaurant Hours

Tuesday-Sunday 11AM to 10PM
Closed Mondays

New York Deli Williamsburg

Like New York Deli & Pizza Restaurant on Facebook!